STLD

Steel Dynamics

$222.90

+0.45%
Nov 6, 2026
Bobby Quantitative Model
Steel Dynamics Inc. is a domestic U.S. steel producer and metals recycler operating across four reportable segments — steel operations (hot-rolled, cold-rolled, and coated sheet plus plate), metals recycling and ferrous resources, steel fabrication (joists and deck), and a newer aluminum rolling platform — with the steel operations segment generating the overwhelming majority of revenue. The company is best characterized as a low-cost, highly efficient electric-arc-furnace (EAF) operator with a vertically integrated recycling feedstock model, distinguishing it from blast-furnace peers through superior through-cycle utilization and cost flexibility. The current investor narrative centers on an earnings upcycle: Q3 2026 revenue jumped 34.8% year over year to $6.51 billion with record shipments, industry-leading utilization, and a reported 50% backlog increase, while protective tariffs have widened the competitive gap between efficient EAF producers like STLD and higher-fixed-cost rivals. Debate now hinges on whether steel pricing and demand strength can persist into 2027, how quickly the aluminum rolling mill ramps toward profitability, and whether the stock's 58.8% one-year run has already discounted the cyclical peak.

People also watch

Nucor

Nucor

NUE

Analysis
Reliance, Inc.

Reliance, Inc.

RS

Analysis
Carpenter Technology Corporation

Carpenter Technology Corporation

CRS

Analysis
Cleveland-Cliffs

Cleveland-Cliffs

CLF

Analysis
Commercial Metals Company

Commercial Metals Company

CMC

Analysis

BobbyInvestment Opinion: Should I buy STLD Today?

Rating: Hold (accumulate on weakness). The core thesis is that STLD is a high-quality, low-cost EAF steel producer in the middle of a genuine earnings inflection — Q3 2026 revenue up 34.8% to $6.51 billion, net income more than doubling to $756 million, and gross margin expanding to 19.58% — but after a 58.8% one-year gain the stock already reflects much of that upcycle, leaving only +10.1% upside to the $272.68 average analyst target. The consensus "buy" rating (9 Buy, 4 Hold, 1 Sell; mean 2.0) and the wide $205.45–$310.00 target range confirm the debate is about cycle timing, not business quality.

Supporting evidence is strong on fundamentals: the forward P/E of 11.57x on consensus EPS of $16.19 is less than half the 21.13x trailing multiple, implying the market expects earnings to roughly double; quarterly gross margin has climbed sequentially from 14.66% (Q1) to 15.74% (Q2) to 19.58% (Q3), showing operating leverage still building; TTM free cash flow of $1.09 billion funds $275.6 million of Q3 buybacks and $76.1 million of dividends at a conservative 24.6% payout; and the balance sheet is fortress-like with debt-to-equity of 0.47, current ratio of 3.06, and interest coverage near 25.6x. The counterweight is valuation: at 13.47x EV/EBITDA STLD trades above the roughly 8–10x typical for integrated steel peers, and the 3-month change of -6.88% (underperforming SPY by 4.87 points) shows momentum has faded.

The rating would upgrade to Buy if the stock pulls back toward the $219–$221 near-term support (roughly 11.6% below spot, implying ~10x forward EPS) while the 50% backlog continues converting into record shipments, or if the aluminum rolling mill reaches profitability ahead of schedule. It would downgrade to Sell if steel spreads normalize sharply and consensus EPS of $16.19 is revised materially lower, or if the stock breaks below $219 and confirms a lower-highs structure toward $200. On balance the stock is fairly valued to modestly undervalued on forward earnings but expensive on trailing and EV/EBITDA bases — a cyclical leader priced for a durable upcycle, not a bargain.

Sign up to view all

STLD 12-Month Price Forecast

STLD presents a high-quality cyclical with accelerating fundamentals — 34.8% revenue growth, net income more than doubling to $756 million, and a 50% backlog increase — but the stock has already rallied 58.8% in a year and offers just 10.1% upside to the average analyst target. The forward P/E of 11.57x is undemanding if consensus EPS of $16.19 materializes, yet the 13.47x EV/EBITDA premium to peers and the -6.88% three-month momentum fade argue for patience rather than chasing. The 25/50/25 bull/base/bear weighting reflects a market that is fairly priced for a durable upcycle, with the key swing factor being whether steel spreads hold into 2027. I would upgrade to bullish on a pullback toward $219–$221 (roughly 10x forward EPS) or on confirmation that the aluminum mill is profitable, and downgrade to bearish if steel prices roll over and consensus EPS is revised lower.

Historical Price
Current Price $222.90
Average Target $261.34
High Target $310.00
Low Target $205.45

Wall Street consensus

Most Wall Street analysts maintain a constructive view on Steel Dynamics's 12-month outlook, with a consensus price target around $272.68 and implied upside of +22.3% versus the current price.

Average Target

$272.68

14 analysts

Implied Upside

+22.3%

vs. current price

Analyst Count

14

covering this stock

Price Range

$205 - $310

Analyst target range

Buy
9 (64%)
Hold
4 (29%)
Sell
1 (7%)

Coverage is solid with 14 analysts: 9 Buy, 4 Hold, and 1 Sell, yielding a consensus recommendation of "buy" (mean rating 2.0 on a 1–5 scale). The average target price of $272.68 implies +10.1% upside from the current $247.66, a moderate rather than aggressive bullish stance that reflects the stock's already-large 58.8% one-year gain. Institutional ratings show persistent conviction from the bulls — Barclays, KeyBanc, and Wells Fargo have all reiterated Overweight ratings as recently as October 2026 — while JP Morgan and UBS remain Neutral, suggesting the debate is about timing and cycle durability rather than business quality.

The target range of $205.45 to $310.00 is wide (a spread of roughly 51% of the current price), signaling meaningful disagreement about the cycle. The $310 high target implies multiple expansion toward 19x forward EPS of $16.19 and assumes steel pricing holds, the aluminum ramp succeeds, and the 50% backlog converts into sustained record shipments. The $205.45 low target implies roughly 12.7x forward EPS — essentially pricing in margin compression and a normalization of steel spreads from current elevated levels. Consensus estimated revenue of $24.28 billion (range $22.47–$25.56 billion) versus the current run-rate of roughly $22.2 billion annualized from Q3 supports modest further growth; the wide dispersion and the fact that the average target sits only ~10% above spot suggest analysts see the stock as fairly valued near-term, with the risk/reward skewed by cyclical timing rather than by clear fundamental mispricing.

Drowning in data?

Find the real signal!

Bulls vs Bears: STLD Investment Factors

The bull case rests on a genuine earnings inflection — Q3 2026 revenue up 34.8% to $6.51 billion, net income more than doubling to $756 million, and gross margin expanding to 19.58% — combined with a forward P/E of 11.57x that looks cheap if consensus EPS of $16.19 is achieved. The bear case centers on cyclical timing: the stock has already rallied 58.8% in a year, trades at a premium 13.47x EV/EBITDA versus steel peers, and offers only 10.1% upside to the average analyst target of $272.68. On balance, the bull evidence is currently stronger because the fundamental momentum is accelerating and the forward valuation is undemanding, but the margin of safety is thin after the large run. The single most important tension is whether steel pricing and demand strength persist into 2027 — if they do, the forward multiple is a bargain; if they roll over, the trailing 21.13x P/E would prove expensive and the stock could retest its $219 support.

Bullish

  • Earnings inflection with accelerating margins: Q3 2026 net income of $756 million more than doubled from $404 million a year earlier, while gross margin expanded from 15.70% to 19.58% and operating margin from 10.52% to 15.46%. The sequential progression (gross margin 14.66% in Q1, 15.74% in Q2, 19.58% in Q3) shows operating leverage is still building, not merely stabilizing.
  • Revenue growth of 34.8% with record shipments: Q3 2026 revenue of $6.51 billion grew 34.8% year over year from $4.83 billion, with sequential gains from $5.20 billion in Q1 and $6.09 billion in Q2. Management reported record shipments, industry-leading utilization, and a 50% backlog increase, giving the top-line inflection forward visibility.
  • Forward valuation at 11.57x is undemanding: The forward P/E of 11.57x on consensus EPS of $16.19 is less than half the trailing multiple of 21.13x, implying the market expects earnings to roughly double. If that EPS materializes, the stock trades at a discount to its own recent P/E history (10.5x–23.1x) despite 34.8% revenue growth.
  • Low-cost EAF model and tariff tailwind: As a vertically integrated electric-arc-furnace operator with recycling feedstock, STLD benefits from protective tariffs that widen the gap versus higher-fixed-cost blast-furnace peers. This structural cost advantage supports through-cycle utilization and margin resilience, as evidenced by the 19.58% quarterly gross margin.

Bearish

  • Cyclical peak risk after 58.8% one-year run: The stock has gained 58.8% over the past year versus 10.4% for SPY, a 48.4-point relative advantage, and trades at $247.66, about 14.2% below its 52-week high of $288.74. Much of the upcycle may already be discounted, and the 3-month change of -6.88% underperforming SPY by 4.87 points suggests momentum has faded.
  • Analyst upside limited to 10.1%: The average target price of $272.68 implies only +10.1% upside from $247.66, a moderate stance for a stock with a beta of 1.443. The wide target range of $205.45 to $310.00 (a 51% spread) signals meaningful disagreement about cycle durability rather than a clear mispricing.
  • EV/EBITDA premium to steel peers: At 13.47x EV/EBITDA, STLD trades above the roughly 8–10x range typical for integrated steel peers during upcycles. This premium is defensible given superior utilization, but it leaves little room for error if steel spreads normalize from elevated levels.
  • Earnings quality dependent on steel pricing: The trailing P/E of 21.13x is near the top of its own recent band, and the forward multiple of 11.57x assumes consensus EPS of $16.19 materializes. If steel prices roll over, the trailing multiple would prove expensive and the forward earnings estimate could be revised sharply lower.

STLD Technical Analysis

STLD is in a sustained, powerful uptrend, with a 1-year price change of +58.79% versus just +10.39% for SPY — a relative strength advantage of 48.40 percentage points. At $247.66, the stock sits at roughly 70.5% of its 52-week range of $150.03 to $288.74, meaning it is in the upper half of its band but still about 14.2% below the 52-week high, having consolidated rather than extended to new highs. This positioning is characteristic of a healthy uptrend digesting gains rather than a blow-off top, though the failure to reclaim the $288.74 high leaves the stock vulnerable to a lower-highs pattern if momentum fades. The YTD gain of +40.67% versus SPY's +10.62% confirms the stock has been a decisive market leader through 2026.

Short-term momentum is mixed and reveals a notable divergence: the stock is up +6.75% over the past month (beating SPY's -1.99% by 8.74 points) but down -6.88% over three months, underperforming SPY by 4.87 points in that window. This pattern — strong 1-month recovery inside a weak 3-month stretch — suggests the Q3 earnings-driven rally (revenue +34.8% YoY, record shipments) has arrested a mid-year pullback rather than confirming a fresh leg higher. The 6-month change of +6.33% is modest relative to the 1-year gain, indicating most of the annual advance occurred in the first half of the period and the stock has since traded in a wide $219–$289 consolidation. Volume of roughly 808,000 shares and a short ratio of 4.14 days suggest no aggressive bearish positioning, but also no squeeze dynamic to fuel a breakout.

Key technical levels are well defined: support sits at the 52-week low of $150.03, with a more relevant near-term floor around the August/September lows of $219.00–$221.61, while resistance is the 52-week high of $288.74. A breakout above $288.74 would signal the market is pricing a full cyclical upcycle and likely open a new leg higher; a breakdown below $219 would confirm a lower-highs structure and target the $200 area. With a beta of 1.443, STLD is roughly 44% more volatile than the market, and a max drawdown of -22.55% over the period underscores that position sizing must account for amplified cyclical swings — a 1.5 beta means a 10% market decline could translate to a mid-teens drawdown in STLD.

Beta

1.44

1.44x market volatility

Max Drawdown

-22.6%

Largest decline past year

52-Week Range

$150-$289

Price range past year

Annual Return

+45.8%

Cumulative gain past year

PeriodSTLD ReturnS&P 500
1m-4.8%-5.0%
3m-15.1%-4.9%
6m-5.2%-0.5%
1y+45.8%+9.6%
ytd+26.6%+7.8%

Bobby - Your AI Investment Partner

Get real-time data, AI-driven personalized investment analysis to make smarter investment decisions

STLD Fundamental Analysis

Revenue is accelerating sharply: Q3 2026 revenue of $6.51 billion grew 34.8% year over year versus $4.83 billion in Q3 2025, and the sequential trajectory is equally strong — $5.20 billion in Q1, $6.09 billion in Q2, and $6.51 billion in Q3, with gross profit rising from $763 million to $1.27 billion across those quarters. Segment data shows steel operations contributing $4.52 billion, metals recycling $1.26 billion, and steel fabrication $469 million, confirming that the core steel mill business is the primary growth engine. The reported 50% backlog jump and record shipments imply this revenue momentum has forward visibility, which materially strengthens the investment case for a cyclical name where top-line inflection is typically the leading indicator of earnings revisions.

Profitability has inflected decisively: Q3 2026 net income of $756 million compares with $404 million a year earlier, and net margin expanded from 8.36% to 11.61% over that span. Gross margin followed the same path — 15.70% in Q3 2025 to 19.58% in Q3 2026 — while operating margin reached 15.46% versus 10.52% a year prior, and EBITDA margin improved to 18.15% from 13.79%. The quarterly progression (gross margin 14.66% in Q1, 15.74% in Q2, 19.58% in Q3) shows margin expansion is accelerating, not merely stabilizing, which is the hallmark of operating leverage in a rising steel-price environment. For a commodity steel producer, a ~19.6% gross margin is strong and consistent with STLD's low-cost EAF positioning.

Balance sheet and cash flow metrics are solid: debt-to-equity of 0.47, current ratio of 3.06, and interest coverage of roughly 25.6x indicate ample liquidity and low financial risk, while TTM free cash flow of $1.09 billion and Q3 FCF of $696 million demonstrate the business funds itself internally. ROE of 13.24% and ROA of 9.45% are respectable for a capital-intensive steel producer, and the company returned capital aggressively in Q3 — $275.6 million in buybacks and $76.1 million in dividends against $149.6 million of capex. The one caution is that Q1 2026 FCF was only $10.3 million due to a $459 million working-capital build, showing cash generation is cyclical and inventory-intensive; nonetheless, the dividend yield of 1.16% with a payout ratio of just 24.6% leaves substantial room for continued buybacks and growth investment.

Quarterly Revenue

$6.5B

2026-09

Revenue YoY Growth

+34.8%

YoY Comparison

Gross Margin

19.6%

Latest Quarter

Free Cash Flow

$1.1B

Last 12 Months

Revenue & Net Income Trends (2 Years)

Revenue Breakdown

Metals Recycling and Ferrous Resources Operations
Steel Fabrication Operations
Steel Operations

Open an Account, get $2 TSLA now!

Valuation Analysis: Is STLD Overvalued?

Because STLD is solidly profitable (Q3 net income of $756 million), I lead with the P/E ratio: the trailing P/E is 21.13x while the forward P/E is just 11.57x, an unusually wide gap that implies the market expects earnings to roughly double. That expectation is corroborated by consensus estimated EPS of $16.19 versus a trailing EPS figure near $12.2 (derived from the 21.13x multiple on the $247.66 price), and the forward multiple of 11.57x is remarkably cheap for a company growing revenue 34.8% — the market is clearly discounting the durability of peak-cycle steel earnings.

On peer comparison, STLD trades at a P/S of 1.38x, P/B of 2.80x, and EV/EBITDA of 13.47x, with a net margin of 6.52% and gross margin of 13.01% on a trailing basis (the quarterly figures of 11.61% and 19.58% are far stronger, reflecting the earnings inflection). The 13.47x EV/EBITDA sits above the roughly 8–10x range typical for integrated steel peers during upcycles, a premium that is defensible given STLD's superior utilization, EAF cost structure, and recycling integration, but it also means the stock is not cheap on an asset or sales basis. The PEG ratio of -1.12 is not meaningful due to negative historical earnings growth in the denominator, so forward earnings power rather than trailing growth is the correct anchor.

Historically, STLD's P/E has ranged from roughly 2.5x–3.6x in the 2022 boom, 5.6x–7.7x in mid-2023, and 10.5x–23.1x over the past year, with the current 21.13x trailing multiple near the top of its own recent band. However, the historical P/S of 4.2x–5.6x reported in the ratio history appears to use a different share-count basis than the current 1.38x figure, so the more reliable signal is the P/E: at 21.13x trailing but 11.57x forward, the stock is priced for an earnings recovery that has already begun (Q3 EPS of $5.29 annualizes to roughly $21). If forward EPS of $16.19 materializes, the stock trades at a discount to its own history; if steel prices roll over, the trailing multiple would prove expensive.

PE

21.1x

Latest Quarter

vs. Historical

High-End

5-Year PE Range 3x~23x

vs. Industry Avg

21.1x

Industry PE ~21.1x*

EV/EBITDA

13.5x

Enterprise Value Multiple

Investment Risk Disclosure

Financial and operational risks are moderate but real. The company carries debt-to-equity of 0.47 and interest coverage near 25.6x, so leverage is not a near-term threat, but cash generation is cyclical: Q1 2026 free cash flow was just $10.3 million due to a $459 million working-capital build, versus $696 million in Q3. Revenue is concentrated in steel operations ($4.52 billion of $6.51 billion in Q3), leaving results highly sensitive to steel spreads; a normalization from current elevated levels would pressure the 19.58% gross margin. Additionally, the aluminum rolling mill ramp is a capital-intensive growth project whose profitability timeline remains uncertain and could weigh on returns if delays occur.

Market and competitive risks are elevated given the stock's 58.8% one-year gain and 1.443 beta. At 13.47x EV/EBITDA, STLD trades above the 8–10x typical for integrated steel peers, leaving room for multiple compression if the cycle turns or if tariff support weakens. The 3-month relative underperformance of 4.87 points versus SPY suggests momentum is already fading, and the wide analyst target range of $205.45 to $310.00 reflects disagreement about cycle durability. Competitive dynamics are favorable due to the low-cost EAF model, but a surge in imports or a policy shift on tariffs could erode the pricing advantage that has driven recent record results.

In a worst-case scenario, a sharp decline in steel prices combined with a delayed aluminum ramp and inventory destocking could drive earnings back toward 2025 levels, when quarterly EPS was $1.45–$2.75 versus $5.29 in Q3 2026. The stock's 52-week low of $150.03 represents a 39.4% decline from the current $247.66, and the analyst low target of $205.45 implies a 17.0% downside. A realistic bear case would see the stock retest the $219 near-term support (down 11.6%) and potentially the $200 area (down 19.2%) if the cycle rolls over, with the 52-week low as the extreme downside. Given the 1.443 beta and -22.55% max drawdown over the period, position sizing should account for amplified cyclical swings.

FAQ

The most severe risk is cyclical earnings compression: steel operations generated $4.52 billion of Q3's $6.51 billion revenue, so a normalization of steel spreads from elevated levels would hit the 19.58% gross margin and could force consensus EPS of $16.19 sharply lower, making the 21.13x trailing P/E look expensive. Second is valuation/multiple risk — at 13.47x EV/EBITDA versus the 8–10x peer range, a re-rating toward peers alone would erase a meaningful portion of the current price. Third is policy and competitive risk: the tariff-driven advantage over blast-furnace peers could narrow if trade policy shifts or imports surge, and the aluminum rolling mill ramp carries execution and capital-cost risk. Fourth is cash-flow cyclicality — Q1 2026 free cash flow was just $10.3 million on a $459 million working-capital build, showing how quickly the $1.09 billion TTM FCF can compress, all amplified by a 1.443 beta and a -22.55% max drawdown.

The scenario framework is 25% bull / 50% base / 25% bear. The base case (50% probability, $250–$272.68) assumes steel spreads normalize modestly, revenue tracks the $24.28 billion consensus, EPS lands near $16.19, and the stock drifts toward the $272.68 average target without multiple expansion. The bull case (25%, $288.74–$310.00) requires steel pricing to hold into 2027, the 50% backlog to convert into record shipments, and the aluminum mill to ramp toward profitability, supporting multiple expansion toward 19x forward EPS and the $310 high target. The bear case (25%, $205.45–$219.00) assumes steel prices roll over, inventory destocking reverses the working-capital tailwind, and earnings revert toward 2025 levels (quarterly EPS of $1.45–$2.75 versus $5.29 in Q3 2026), retesting the $219 support and approaching the $205.45 low target. The base case is most likely, and its key assumption is that steel spreads stay healthy enough to deliver consensus EPS.

The answer depends on the metric: at 21.13x trailing P/E STLD sits near the top of its own recent 10.5x–23.1x band, but at 11.57x forward P/E it looks inexpensive relative to its history and to a business growing revenue 34.8%. The market is clearly discounting peak-cycle earnings — the gap between trailing and forward multiples implies earnings are expected to roughly double to $16.19 per share. On EV/EBITDA of 13.47x, however, STLD trades at a premium to the 8–10x typical for integrated steel peers, and its 1.38x P/S and 2.80x P/B are not bargain levels. Net, the stock is fairly valued to modestly undervalued on forward earnings but expensive on trailing and EV/EBITDA bases — the market is paying for quality and cycle durability, not for a discount.

From a risk/reward standpoint STLD is a reasonable but not compelling buy at $247.66: the forward P/E of 11.57x on consensus EPS of $16.19 is cheap if the cycle holds, and the 9 Buy / 4 Hold / 1 Sell consensus with a $272.68 average target implies +10.1% upside. The downside is meaningful, however — the $205.45 analyst low target implies -17.0% and the 52-week low of $150.03 implies -39.4%, and the stock's 1.443 beta means a market pullback would be amplified. The 13.47x EV/EBITDA premium to the 8–10x peer range also limits multiple expansion. It is a good buy primarily for cyclical-tolerant investors who accumulate on weakness toward the $219–$221 support (roughly 10x forward EPS) rather than chasing after a 58.8% one-year gain, and it is less suited to investors needing a margin of safety at today's price.

STLD is better suited to a medium-to-long-term holding period of at least 12–24 months than to short-term trading, because the thesis depends on the steel cycle and the aluminum mill ramp playing out over multiple quarters rather than on a single catalyst. The 1.443 beta and -22.55% max drawdown mean short-term price action is dominated by steel pricing and macro sentiment, making tactical entries difficult to time; the wide $219–$289 consolidation over the past six months illustrates how range-bound the stock can be between earnings events. Long-term holders are compensated modestly along the way with a 1.16% dividend yield at a conservative 24.6% payout ratio, plus buyback support ($275.6 million in Q3 alone) funded by $1.09 billion of TTM free cash flow. A practical approach is to build the position in tranches on pullbacks toward $219–$221 and hold through the cycle, reassessing if gross margin falls back below roughly 15% or if consensus EPS of $16.19 is materially revised lower.